Factual. Independent. Impartial.
Support AAP with a free or paid subscription
FactCheck
Kate Atkinson

Clickbait posts spread fake quotes about Helen Haines

The alleged attack on Helen Haines has sparked a wave of fabricated quotes about the incident. (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS)

What was claimed

Facebook posts include authentic quotes about the alleged attack on Helen Haines.

Our verdict

False. The quotes are fabricated.

AAP FACTCHECK - A Vietnamese Facebook page posing as an Australian news source is posting fake quotes about injured MP Helen Haines.

The fabricated quotes are attributed to the MP's family members, friends and people who witnessed Dr Haines being struck by a vehicle in an allegedly deliberate attack.

Dr Haines had both her legs amputated but is now in a stable condition.

The SixtyOne News Facebook page has posted numerous updates about the incident, which occurred outside her office in Wangaratta, northern Victoria, on October 19.

Screenshot of a fabricated quote about Helen Haines
Facebook pages based in Vietnam are posting fabricated quotes about Helen Haines. (Facebook/AAP)

An October 25 post claims to include a quote from Dr Haines' husband, Phil Haines, who gave a media statement at The Alfred Hospital on October 21.

"I watched our entire world crumble right before me,” the post quotes Mr Haines as saying.

However, Mr Haines never said this during his comments to the media.

He confirmed that Dr Haines required a double amputation and thanked first responders, hospital staff, and other supporters.

The quote attributed to him in the Facebook post does not appear in an ABC News video of the six-minute statement he made at the hospital.

The Facebook posts encourage users to click through to an ad-laden website that repeats the fabricated quote.

Meta transparency information shows the SixtyOne News Facebook page is operated by users from Vietnam.

Other SixtyOne News posts feature fake quotes from local barber Ricky Jefferies, who witnessed the alleged attack.

Screenshot of a fabricated quote about Helen Haines
Fake quotes are being attributed to eye witnesses, family members and even Helen Haines herself. (Facebook/AAP)

"In a shocking turn of events, Ricky Jefferies has broken the silence to expose an agonizing truth that no one saw coming,” one post says.

It then quotes Mr Jefferies as saying: “I couldn't save her from terror!"

Another post by the page claims Mr Jefferies said Dr Haines’ “terrifying cries still haunt me every night".

But a search of his public statements and comments after the attack finds no record of him saying this.

Phil Haines, husband of Helen Haines, speaking to media on October 21
Phil Haines spoke to media at The Alfred Hospital but did not say the words attributed to him. (Jay Kogler/AAP PHOTOS)

Mr Jefferies was interviewed by multiple news outlets, where he described the scene and how he intervened to pull the alleged attacker from the vehicle.

He told the media he was humbled and grateful to have been able to help.

Another post claims to reveal the first words Dr Haines said after waking up in hospital.

"As reported by ABC News, independent MP Allegra Spender broke down in parliament to reveal the first words spoken by Helen Haines after waking up from life-saving surgeries," the caption reads.

"'I saw his face clearly': Helen Haines speaks upon waking after brutal truck a**ack," the caption of an image in the post reads.

Allegra Spender MP during tributes to Helen Haines, October 26, 2026
MP Allegra Spender paid tribute to Helen Haines in a parliamentary speech on October 26, 2026. (Mick Tsikas/AAP PHOTOS)

While Ms Spender did speak about Dr Haines in parliament, Hansard transcripts show she did not say Dr Haines’s first words were “I saw his face clearly”.

“Phil told us about your first words when you woke up after the attack,” Ms Spender said in parliament.

“Your first concerns when you awoke were for your staff and gratitude to the first responders, nurses and bystanders," Ms Spender said.

“That exactly speaks to the character of who you are."

Multiple other foreign-run Facebook pages publishing clickbait about Australian current affairs have shared similar fabricated quotes relating to the alleged attack.

AAP FactCheck is an accredited member of the International Fact-Checking Network. To keep up with our latest fact checks, follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, X, BlueSky, TikTok and YouTube.

Sign up to read this article for free
Choose between a free or paid subscription to AAP News
Start reading
Already a member? Sign in here
Top stories on AAP right now