Factual. Independent. Impartial.
Support AAP with a free or paid subscription
Courts
Andrew Stafford

Expert says mum's fatal injuries could be from falls

Frances Crawford, 49, was found dead in her pyjamas near a ride-on mower in 2024. (PR IMAGE PHOTO)

Traumatic head, neck and chest injuries suffered by a woman could have been caused by an accidental fall from a lawnmower, an expert has told a jury.

However, extensive bruising and marks to the neck and chin area of Frances Crawford could be consistent with manual strangulation, the same expert said.

Robert Crawford, 49, is accused of murdering his wife then staging her death to appear that she died as the result of a fall from a ride-on mower on the couple's property west of Brisbane on July 29, 2024.

The jury was shown a series of graphic post-mortem photos of Ms Crawford, prompting several members of the public gallery to leave the court.

Robert Crawford
The prosecution has cast former RAAF pilot Robert John Crawford as a love rat and master manipulator (Darren England/AAP PHOTOS)

Jason Payne-James, a UK-based specialist in forensic and legal medicine, was called by Crawford's barrister Saul Holt KC to review Ms Crawford's case.

He was instructed to compare the likelihood of the prosecution's case - that Crawford had strangled his wife - with the accidental scenario.

Professor Payne-James was asked about two dark abrasions under the left side of Ms Crawford's jaw.

"If you see circular injuries to the neck, where there is a possibility of, for example, manual strangulation, you question whether or not these may represent fingernail bruises or marks," he said.

He said the specific nature of Ms Crawford's injuries was inconsistent with being placed in a chokehold.

woman at cafe
Frances Crawford, 49, was weighing up whether to leave her unfaithful husband before her death. (HANDOUT/QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE)

Pathologist Andrzej Kedziora, who performed the autopsy, previously gave evidence that the bruises may have been caused by Ms Crawford's fingers or knuckles trying to remove something from her neck.

Prof Payne-James agreed that was a possibility.

On the extensive abrasions to Ms Crawford's throat, Mr Holt asked Prof Payne-James if it was possible to distinguish between the rubbing of a steering wheel and the rubbing of fabric.

"No ... It would be consistent with both," Prof Payne-James replied.

In cross-examination, prosecutor Chris Cook put it to Prof Payne-James that he was not a pathologist.

Prof Payne-James replied that he was akin to a pathologist in that he was a medical doctor whose area of expertise was injury interpretation and documentation.

"Mrs Crawford has multiple blunt-force injuries which, from a medical perspective, could be explained by falls, by tumbling, by being impacted or contacted by anything," he said.

The trial, now in its fourth week, continues.

Sign up to read this article for free
Choose between a free or paid subscription to AAP News
Start reading
Already a member? Sign in here
Top stories on AAP right now