Factual. Independent. Impartial.
Support AAP with a free or paid subscription
Politics
Nick Wilson

'High risk': election debates have become the debate

There'll be no one-on-one showdown between Ben Carroll and Jess Wilson in the sole election debate. (Joanna Kordina/AAP PHOTOS)

The leaders of all four major Victorian political parties are preparing to face off in the only pre-election debate the two major contenders could agree to. 

In another sign of the unconventionality of the campaign ahead of the November 28 poll, Victorians have so far been denied a one-on-one showdown between the leaders of the two major parties. 

Instead, Premier Ben Carroll and Opposition Leader Jess Wilson will on Tuesday be joined by their Greens and One Nation counterparts for a town hall-style debate. 

It follows weeks of posturing from the two major parties, whose leaders have been at loggerheads over who they should share the stage with. 

Victorian Premier Ben Carroll
The debate is a chance for Ben Carroll to speak to voters who have drifted away from Labor. (Con Chronis/AAP PHOTOS)

The matter could be reduced to one thing: risk avoidance, political scientist Zareh Ghazarian said. 

"There's been a very centralised and very professional campaign by both major parties," he told AAP. 

Labor and the coalition had run largely gaffe-free campaigns and, in debates, the architects of each likely saw opportunities for slip-ups, the Monash University expert said. 

The conventional wisdom is debates rarely move voters, but they can generate awkward moments capable of dominating a news cycle.

"There is a lot running on this event," Dr Ghazarian said. 

"If there is a gaffe, this is high risk and low reward."

The Herald Sun and News24 will host Tuesday night's debate after other platforms, including Nine, the ABC and the Daily Aus were unable to secure one of the two major party leaders.

Victorian Leader of the Opposition Jess Wilson
Jess Wilson has accused the premier of wanting to avoid a head-to-head showdown. (Jay Kogler/AAP PHOTOS)

Ms Wilson has argued the premier was running scared from the chance for a tete-a-tete between the state's most likely future leaders. 

Mr Carroll has rejected that claim, arguing the Liberal leader was afraid to appear on a stage alongside One Nation.

Dr Ghazarian said the premier would on Tuesday likely attempt to tie the coalition to One Nation, while the former would similarly look to cast Labor and the Greens as bedfellows. 

Of the two major parties, Labor likely has the most to gain and the coalition, the poll favourite, the most to lose, he said. 

"Where the Liberals have been gaining support, Labor's been losing support," he said. 

"This is the opportunity for Ben Carroll to speak to those members."

One Nation’s Warren Pickering during a media conference in Melbourne
One Nation’s Warren Pickering may benefit simply by appearing on stage with the established parties. (Christopher Hopkins/AAP PHOTOS)

But, he said, One Nation, under the leadership of Warren Pickering, was likely the default beneficiary, merely by appearing on stage with more established rivals. 

"For a party that's never been able to win a seat in the lower house to have that same platform, I think speaks volumes," Dr Ghazarian said. 

Head-to-head leaders debates are standard features of elections. 

Victorians were treated to only one such debate in 2022, but the most recent federal election boasted four. 

The November election is more fractious than most, but voters would still benefit from a formal head-to-head, Dr Ghazarian said. 

"These sorts of events allow leaders to be in pressure-tested situations and we haven't really seen either leader in those situations," he said. 

"There is a bit of a missed opportunity here."

License this article

Sign up to read this article for free
Choose between a free or paid subscription to AAP News
Start reading
Already a member? Sign in here
Top stories on AAP right now