Factual. Independent. Impartial.
Support AAP with a free or paid subscription
General
Duncan Murray

'Orwellian': Jewish group pushes back on envoy report

A report on anti-Semitism has been criticised for not representing the views of all Jews. (Dean Lewins/AAP PHOTOS)

Some Australian Jews could themselves be labelled anti-Semitic under the definitions presented in a new report, one group says.

The report released on Friday by Australia's Special Envoy to Combat anti-Semitism, Jillian Segal, identified "progressive’" anti-Semitism as the most pervasive form facing the country.

"Islamic extremist, far-left and far-right anti-Semitism are still very much with us," Ms Segal said.

Australia's Special Envoy to Combat anti-Semitism Jillian Segal
Jillian Segal has called for anti-Semitism in influential institutions to be stamped out. (Dan Himbrechts/AAP PHOTOS)

"But the form that is leaving Jewish Australians increasingly anxious and excluded is the one that has taken root in influential institutions, where Jewish Australians are being discriminated against, blamed and vilified for the actions of the government of the State of Israel."

Ms Segel stressed, however, that criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country was not anti-Semitic.

Executive officer at the Jewish Council of Australia, Bart Shteinman slammed the report calling it "Orwellian" and saying it does not represent the views of all Jews.

"This updated report from the Special Envoy is so misguided, conspiratorial and frankly Orwellian that it’s hard to know where to start," he said.

"The report does little to mask a right-wing ideology that will go to incredible lengths to silence those drawing attention to Israel’s genocide in Gaza.

"The Australian Government would do well to remember that the special envoy does not speak for all Jews, many of whom could be classified as 'progressive anti-Semites' themselves under the ridiculous analysis Segal is promoting."

The report suggested "progressive anti-Semitism" could manifest as holding all Jewish people responsible for the actions of the Israeli Government.

Tributes for Bondi terror attack victims
Opponents labelled the report, sparked by the Bondi terror attacks, misguided and Orwellian. (Dean Lewins/AAP PHOTOS)

The December 2025 Bondi shooting, in which 15 people were killed, exposed how the normalisation of anti-Semitism could not be separated from threats of extremism and violence, according to Ms Segal.

"Bondi exposed with devastating clarity that the normalisation of anti-Semitism in our institutions and public discourse cannot be separated from the threat of extremism and violence," she said.

A main priority of the latest report was the continued embedment of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of anti-Semitism by the Australian Government, which has faced criticism as overly prohibitive of certain speech.

The alliance considers a denial of the Jewish people’s right to self-determination to constitute anti-Semitism, with the report stating Zionism to be a form of Jewish self determination within their "ancestral homeland".

The report suggested it had become common, to avoid appearing "transparently and obviously anti-Semitic", to use language which targeted Zionists rather than Jews.

The alliance definition does not consider criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country as anti-Semitic.

Ms Segel identified as a priority education efforts to reduce anti-Semitism across schools, universities, business and the private sector including the ongoing use of the alliance definition.

License this article

Sign up to read this article for free
Choose between a free or paid subscription to AAP News
Start reading
Already a member? Sign in here
Top stories on AAP right now