Factual. Independent. Impartial.
Support AAP with a free or paid subscription
Courts
Tara Cosoleto

'I despise you': sister's anger as she confronts killer

Mark Ludbrook watched from prison as his murder victim's family spoke of their anger and grief. (Con Chronis/AAP PHOTOS)

Sky Daly-Holt was cradling her six-week-old daughter when she received the news no loved one wants to hear. 

Her sister Autumn Baker had been violently murdered by a man she had considered a friend.

"What should have been a joyous time in my life ... turned into a horror show," Ms Daly-Holt said.

Autumn Baker
Autumn Baker was violently murdered by a man she considered her friend. (PR IMAGE PHOTO)

Ms Baker had been visiting Mark Ludbrook at his home in Melbourne's southwest in August 2023 when he attacked her with a knife. 

She had tried to stop him from self-harming when he turned the weapon on her, stabbing her multiple times to the chest, arms and eyes. 

Ludbrook claimed his mind was altered by PCE, an illicit drug he had taken earlier that morning to manage pain from his neurological condition.

But a Victorian Supreme Court jury found the 54-year-old was conscious of his actions and therefore guilty of murder.

Ms Daly-Holt was among Ms Baker's friends and family who confronted Ludbrook as he faced a pre-sentence hearing on Tuesday. 

She described the violence and sorrow he had brought into her life, saying Ludbrook had destroyed her family. 

Mark Ludbrook (file)
Mark Ludbrook claimed his mind was altered by an illicit drug he had taken to manage pain. (Con Chronis/AAP PHOTOS)

"You have stolen my first and forever friend, my childhood witness, a person who knew me better than anyone else," Ms Daly-Holt said.

"Every day I tell Autumn I love her and I miss her. No one will love me like Autumn did."

Ludbrook had also robbed Ms Baker's two young children of a loving, caring and empathetic mother, Ms Daly-Holt said.

"I despise you," she told Ludbrook, who watched on a video link from prison.

"I wish Autumn had never met you. I wish she had let you kill yourself that day. Your life is worthless."

Ms Baker's mother Annie Daly-Holt said she was afraid to live each day without her daughter and it was only her grandchildren who kept her going.

"My life has been about ensuring my daughter is not forgotten," she said.

"She was exuding light everywhere she went and left beauty in her wake. There was nothing she couldn't do."

Ms Baker's father Lance Daly-Holt said there was no adequate sentence for Ludbrook. 

Prosecutor Jim Shaw (file)
Prosecutor Jim Shaw said Mark Ludbrook still hadn't taken any responsibility for his actions. (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS)

"I miss my daughter every day," he said.

"This man's actions have taken everything from my family."

On the morning of the murder, Ludbrook's carer saw him walking around naked despite him normally only managing three steps at a time.

He also thanked different colours and told his carer how he needed to sleep with her to save the animals.

Crown prosecutor Jim Shaw said the verdict made it clear Ludbrook was acting consciously and deliberately at the time of the murder, regardless of the drugs he had taken.

Lubdrook's moral culpability was therefore high and he still had not taken any responsibility for his actions, Mr Shaw argued.

Ludbrook's barrister will make submissions when the case returns to court on Friday.

Lifeline 13 11 14

beyondblue 1300 22 4636

Sign up to read this article for free
Choose between a free or paid subscription to AAP News
Start reading
Already a member? Sign in here
Top stories on AAP right now