Factual. Independent. Impartial.
Support AAP with a free or paid subscription
Courts
Tara Cosoleto

Jurors dismiss pier killer's bloody pants claims

Andres Pancha, 45, was fishing on Frankston Pier when stabbed by a stranger 101 times. (Jay Kogler/AAP PHOTOS)

A homeless man arrested in blood-splattered pants has been found guilty of stabbing an unsuspecting fisherman to death. 

Forest Stevenson, 38, denied he was the one who attacked Andres Pancha, 45, at Frankston Pier in Melbourne's southeast in June 2024.

But a Victorian Supreme Court jury on Thursday found him guilty of murder after close to three days of deliberations.

Jurors found Stevenson attacked Mr Pancha on the pier after approaching him about 6am on June 29.

Using a knife, Mr Pancha stabbed the older man 101 times, including 31 blows to the head and neck, and 40 to the torso.

Another fisherman who was about 100 metres away called triple zero while Stevenson fled the scene on foot.

courthouse sign
Jurors deliberated for almost three days before finding Stevenson guilty of murder. (Joel Carrett/AAP PHOTOS)

Paramedics arrived at 6.12am to find Mr Pancha lying in a pool of blood with no pulse.

Police immediately reviewed CCTV footage and identified the attacker as a man in a green jacket.

About 80 minutes after the fatal stabbing, Stevenson was found lying in shrub, dressed in a green jacket with blood-stained black pants.

Mr Pancha was a likely contributor of the DNA found on Stevenson's pants, crown prosecutor Kristie Churchill KC told jurors

She also said the CCTV of the man leaving the scene matched footage of Stevenson in the Frankston area before the attack.

But defence barrister Amy Brennan told jurors the man in the footage was not her client and the pants he was arrested in were not his. 

Jurors began their deliberations on Tuesday morning and returned their guilty verdict on Thursday afternoon.

Mr Pancha's family broke down into sobs and hugged each other after the verdict was handed down.

They declined to speak to media after the verdict.

Stevenson will face a pre-sentence hearing at a later date. 

Sign up to read this article for free
Choose between a free or paid subscription to AAP News
Start reading
Already a member? Sign in here
Top stories on AAP right now